The Best of Peer-Reviewed Management Research

Cutting edge insights extracted from peer-reviewed studies from the latest and most highly reputed research journals. Save time and become a smarter leader. Bite-sized learning on your own schedule. Constantly updated and ever growing.

3 minute quick summaries

Research insights curated from the these top universities and more.

How Do Teams Become Cohesive?

Research and Meta-Analysis from University of Central Florida

📋 Introduction

Paper Title: How Do Teams Become Cohesive? A Meta-Analysis of Cohesion's Antecedents
Year of Publication: 2014
Journal: Electronic Theses and Dissertations, University of Central Florida
Author: Rebecca Grossman (University of Central Florida)

Why this matters

We all know that team cohesion is critical for performance, yet leaders often struggle with how to actually build it - this research finally provides clear, evidence-based guidance on what actually works in developing team cohesion, moving beyond the common but often ineffective approaches of focusing on personality fits or formal team building exercises.

Findings

This comprehensive meta-analysis examined over 340 studies spanning three decades of research on team cohesion. Here's what emerged as the key drivers of team cohesion:

The strongest relationships came from how teams actually worked together day-to-day, rather than who was on the team. Communication quality, workload sharing, and trust showed the strongest positive relationships with cohesion. Interestingly, team composition and personality fits, while still relevant, showed much weaker relationships than expected.

Team interventions like training and team building showed moderate positive effects, but the everyday leadership behaviors and team environment factors had more consistent positive relationships with cohesion. The research also found that providing teams with autonomy and necessary resources had stronger effects than trying to control how teams worked together.

Why this happens

Cohesion appears to develop naturally through meaningful day-to-day interactions rather than through forced team building or careful personality matching. When team members communicate effectively, share work fairly, and build trust through their actions, they develop organic bonds and shared commitment to their goals.

The environment leaders create - through providing autonomy, resources, and support - enables these positive interactions to occur naturally.

The weaker effect of personality and team composition likely occurs because people can learn to work effectively together regardless of their individual traits, as long as the right conditions and behaviors are in place.

This explains why focusing too much on hiring for "culture fit" or personality matching often yields disappointing results.

💡Our recommendation

Your everyday actions will have far more impact on team cohesion than one-off activities.

Create the right environment: Focus on creating the right environment and modeling the right behaviors for cohesion to emerge naturally, rather than trying to force it through team building exercises or perfect personality matches.
Provide the right tools: As a leader, start by ensuring your team has the tools and channels they need for rich communication, especially in remote or hybrid settings.
Provide adequate autonomy: Give them meaningful autonomy in how they approach their work while ensuring they have necessary resources.
Lead by example: Model and encourage behaviors that build trust - like transparent information sharing, fair workload distribution, and supporting team members.
Recognize good work regularly: Make sure to recognize and reinforce moments when team members demonstrate these positive behaviors. Rather than planning formal team building activities, create natural opportunities for meaningful collaboration and relationship building through the actual work your team does.